A year after falling short at the inaugural Northern Super League final, AFC Toronto finally have their championship moment.
Toronto defeated Montréal Roses 1-0 at TD Place in Ottawa on Saturday to claim the Diana B. Matheson Cup and end the 2026 season as NSL champions.
It was a frustrating afternoon for Montréal, who arrived as Supporters’ Shield winners and had not lost in 12 matches. Toronto came out to win, and it was 17-year-old Olivia Chisholm who sealed it.
Her first professional goal, scored just before half-time, proved just about enough to separate the two sides in a final that had very little between them.
Olivia Chisholm delivers when it matters
Montréal began the contest looking to dictate possession, but Toronto were prepared to be patient and exploit opportunities in transition.
The breakthrough arrived in the 39th minute. Lauren Rowe carried the ball down the right flank before finding Chisholm, who took advantage of the space in front of her and fired a right-footed finish into the side netting.
Chisholm had been waiting all season to open her professional account. Instead of arriving in an ordinary league fixture, her first goal came with the Diana B. Matheson Cup on the line.
“I’ve been waiting all season to score my first goal, so pretty good time to score,” she said after the match.
The midfielder explained that she had spotted the space as Montréal’s defensive line dropped back. She trusted Rowe to reach the ball despite a slightly heavier touch and positioned herself to take advantage.
“As it left my foot, I kind of had a good feeling that it was going to go in, and then it did.”
The goal earned Chisholm the Final’s MVP award, capping a memorable performance from one of Toronto’s youngest players.
Sabrina D’Angelo keeps the Roses out
Montréal looked for a response, but Toronto made sure there was little room for the Shield winners to find their way back into the contest.
Sabrina D’Angelo produced three important saves as the Roses looked to get back on level terms. Toronto’s defensive structure became increasingly important as the game wore on, with the team forced to manage Montréal’s attempts to build through possession.
Embed from Getty ImagesFor head coach Marko Milanovic, the final was decided by fine margins rather than a significant difference in quality.
“Little bounces here and there, little details,” he said.
He also praised Montréal’s season, acknowledging the quality of both finalists.
“I think these are the two best teams in the league. You saw it today.”
Toronto’s ability to protect the lead was particularly impressive in the second half. Milanovic felt his players did an excellent job defensively when Montréal began pushing forward.
The challenge was familiar: protect the advantage, remain organized and avoid allowing the occasion to take over.
Nikayla Small: “We weren’t going to lose”
Toronto’s experience of last season’s final gave the squad another reference point heading into Saturday’s game. The players knew what it felt like to come so close and leave without the trophy, losing out to Vancouver. This time, they were determined to finish the job.
Captain Nikayla Small spoke about the mindset she wanted to bring to her new leadership role this season. Her approach was to remain herself, lead by example and become more vocal when the team needed it.
Heading into the final, there was no hesitation about the objective.
Embed from Getty Images“There was only one thing on my mind. We weren’t going to lose,” she said.
Small also highlighted how important it was to share the victory with Toronto’s travelling supporters.
The atmosphere at TD Place featured fans from both clubs, with Toronto and Montréal supporters making the trip to Ottawa. For Small, celebrating with those who had followed the team throughout the season made the championship even more special.
Having already experienced the satisfaction of winning the Supporters’ Shield last season, she admitted that lifting the championship trophy was an entirely different feeling.
“Last year celebrating the Shield, this is even better because it’s the finals,” she said.
Small also added that she already has her sights set on what comes next: winning both trophies in 2027.
Montréal left wondering what might have been
For the Roses, the defeat was a difficult conclusion to an otherwise outstanding season.
Their 12-game unbeaten run came to an end at the worst possible time, with the team unable to turn its possession and attacking opportunities into an equalizer.
Head coach Maryse Bard-Martel was disappointed by the missed chances but refused to let the result overshadow their performance.
“There are some days where the ball just doesn’t go into the net,” she said. “We weren’t able to convert.”
The Roses also felt that Toronto’s approach disrupted their rhythm. Charlotte Bilbault explained that Montréal prefer to build attacks through possession, whereas Toronto were more direct and looked to exploit transitions.
“Toronto played their game — long balls. Sometimes it worked, but we are more of a team that plays with the ball, more focused on possession,” she said.
There was also an acknowledgement that Montréal struggled at certain points to reconnect their attacking and defensive transitions. Against a Toronto side prepared to attack those spaces, the smallest lapse proved costly.
Still, the Roses were keen to put the result into perspective.
They had secured the first Supporters’ Shield in club history, broken records and continued to establish themselves as one of the league’s leading teams.
Bilbault pointed to the club’s development, particularly given that this was only its second season.
“We always want more, but sometimes we mustn’t forget where we come from,” she said.
The disappointment of missing out on the championship was obvious but so was the belief that Montréal can return stronger.
Toronto’s next challenge: defending the crown
Toronto’s championship was built on more than Chisholm’s finishing or D’Angelo’s saves.
The squad benefited from a combination of experienced players and younger talent, with Canadian international additions such as Sabrina D’Angelo and Shelina Zadorsky helping raise the competitive standards within the group.
The coaching staff felt that the veterans brought confidence and experience without taking away opportunities from emerging players.
For Milanovic, maintaining that environment will be important heading into another season.
Embed from Getty ImagesHe also credited the team’s consistent preparation for helping the players manage the additional attention surrounding the final. Toronto approached the championship week much like any other, keeping their training and meeting schedules familiar.
It was a method that ultimately worked in their favour.
The victory also marks another important moment for the NSL. Both finalists were led by Canadian head coaches, something Milanovic believes reflects the opportunities the league can create for domestic coaching talent.
It also marks a new historic landmark for Samantha Chang, former Vancouver Rise FC captain. Although she was sidelined for the 2026 season with her ACL injury, she became the first back-to-back NSL champion, having moved to AFC Toronto earlier this year.
With Winnipeg Ember FC set to join as the seventh club in 2027, the competition continues to grow.
Toronto now have a championship to defend, while Montréal have unfinished business of their own.
For Chisholm, the immediate future can wait. Her first professional goal has already given her a moment she will remember for the rest of her career.